Last updated: December 2025
Quick answer
In a high-rate market, a HELOC is often the smarter option for accessing home equity because it doesn’t disturb your existing low-rate mortgage. A cash-out refinance replaces your entire mortgage at today’s higher rate, which can lead to significantly increased monthly payments.
Access cash within days
Tap into your home’s potential in minutes. Start our streamlined digital application to discover if a HELOC is right for you.
Why home equity access strategy matters when rates are high
When interest rates rise, homeowners with low-rate mortgages face a difficult choice.
You may need to tap into your home’s equity for large expenses, like renovations, tuition, or debt consolidation, but refinancing into a higher rate could increase your total interest costs.
That’s why choosing between a HELOC and a cash-out refinance is critical. Each option has advantages and trade-offs depending on your financial goals and the current rate environment.
What is a home equity line of credit or HELOC?
A home equity line of credit (HELOC) is a revolving credit line secured by your home. It operates like a credit card backed by your property’s equity.
Key HELOC features:
- Second mortgage (your primary mortgage stays unchanged)
- Variable interest rates (usually tied to the prime rate)
- Interest-only payments during the draw period (5–10 years)
- Flexible borrowing as needed
A HELOC is often used when you want to preserve your current low-rate mortgage while still accessing funds.
What is a cash-out refinance?
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a new, larger loan. You receive the difference between your old balance and the new loan amount as a lump sum.
Key cash-out refi features:
- Replaces the current mortgage with a new one
- Typically fixed-rate, 15- to 30-year term
- You pay closing costs and start over on repayment
- Locks in today’s higher rates
Cash-out refinancing is common when rates are low or when consolidating multiple debts into a single loan makes financial sense.
HELOC vs cash-out refinance: Key differences
| Feature | HELOC | Cash-out refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Affects existing mortgage? | No | Yes, it replaces the existing mortgage with a new loan |
| Rate type | Variable | Usually fixed |
| Upfront cash | Borrow as needed | Lump sum at closing |
| Repayment start | Interest-only draw period | Full principal and interest immediately |
| Interest rate impact | No change to locked mortgage | Subject to current market rates |
| Closing costs | Lower | Higher (similar to new mortgage) |
Check your HELOC rate in minutes.
Why HELOCs may be better in a high-rate market
In today’s high-rate market, a HELOC lets you keep your low-rate mortgage intact. That makes it attractive if:
- Your current mortgage rate is significantly below market rates
- You need flexibility in how much and when you borrow
- You want to avoid restarting a 30-year loan term
You only pay interest on what you draw, keeping monthly costs lower during the draw period.
When a cash-out refinance might still make sense
Despite higher rates, a cash-out refinance can be the better choice in some scenarios:
- You already have a high-rate mortgage and want to consolidate debts
- You need a large lump sum and want predictable payments
- You’re okay with extending your mortgage term
- You want to switch from an ARM to a fixed-rate loan
In these cases, even at today’s rates, a refinance may offer long-term savings, especially if used to eliminate high-interest credit card debt.
Real-world example: Monthly payment comparison
Let’s say you have a $300,000 mortgage at 3.25% fixed with 25 years remaining, and you need $50,000 in cash.
Option 1: HELOC (second mortgage)
- Original mortgage: $300,000 at 3.25% (unchanged)
- New HELOC: $50,000 at 8.00% variable
- Monthly HELOC payment (interest-only): ~$333
Option 2: Cash-out refinance
- New mortgage: $350,000 at 7.25% for 30 years
- New monthly payment: ~$2,387
- Old monthly payment (pre-refi): ~$1,460
Result: Your new mortgage payment jumps nearly $927 per month by refinancing at the higher rate.
Additional factors to consider
HELOC advantages:
- No need to touch your low-rate mortgage
- Flexible borrowing during draw period
- Lower upfront costs
HELOC drawbacks:
- Variable rates may rise further
- Repayment period brings higher payments
- Shorter loan term than a refinance
Cash-out refinance advantages:
- Fixed-rate stability
- Simpler repayment structure
- Longer loan term = lower monthly payment (in some cases)
Cash-out refinance drawbacks:
- Higher closing costs
- Replaces your low-rate mortgage
- Interest paid on full lump sum immediately
Credit and eligibility differences
Lenders may apply different qualification standards for each option:
| Requirement | HELOC | Cash-out refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Credit score | 620+ (some flexibility) | 640–680+ |
| Debt-to-income ratio | 43% or lower | Stricter DTI limits |
| Loan-to-value (LTV) | Up to 85% combined LTV | Often max 80% |
| Home appraisal required | Yes | Yes |
Use our calculator to compare your options
Try our HELOC calculator to:
- Estimate how much equity you can access
- Compare HELOC draw vs refinance lump sum
- Understand monthly payment differences
- Decide which option fits your financial goals
Choose the right equity strategy for today’s market with HomeEQ
In a high-rate environment, keeping your low mortgage rate intact is often the most strategic move.
A HELOC offers flexibility, lower upfront costs, and minimal disruption to your finances. It’s often the preferred option for many homeowners right now.
But if your goals or mortgage situation differ, a refinance may still be worth exploring. Compare carefully before committing.
Check your HELOC rate in minutes with HomeEQ.
Frequently asked questions: HELOC vs cash-out refinance in a high-rate market
Q: Why is a HELOC better than a cash-out refinance in a high-rate market?
A: A HELOC doesn’t affect your current mortgage, which likely has a lower rate. A refinance would replace it with a new, higher-rate loan, thereby raising your monthly payments.
Q: Can I refinance later if rates drop?
A: Yes. Many homeowners use a HELOC now and refinance their mortgage later if interest rates decrease. It provides short-term flexibility without locking into higher rates.
Q: Will I pay higher closing costs with a cash-out refinance?
A: Yes. Cash-out refinances often have closing costs similar to buying a new home, typically 2% to 5% of the loan amount. HELOCs usually have lower upfront fees.
Q: Are HELOC payments always interest-only?
A: Only during the draw period (usually 5–10 years). After that, your payments include principal and interest over the repayment period.
Q: How do I choose between a HELOC and a refinance?
A: It depends on your current mortgage rate, how much you need, how long you plan to stay in the home, and your risk tolerance for variable rates.
